- 6261 views
问题: 关于重复率和引用,期刊给了以下回复,我接下来该怎么办呢?
Detailed Question
收到期刊以下回复,怎么办?Although I appreciate the scientific efforts represented by this work, I regret to inform you that there are some issues with the checking for originality. While some of the overlap is the authors' own, and this is acceptable, verbatim reuse, even of one's own words should be minimal (copyright issues are only one factor). Moreover, there are other passages seemingly taken from articles cited in references. These should be rewritten and the sources should better cited and discussed. These issues need to be resolved prior to continue for peer review. I certainly hope you are able to address these issues and submit an new manuscript. Please note that resubmitting your manuscript does not guarantee eventual acceptance, and that your resubmission will be subject to re-review by the reviewer(s) before a decision is rendered
Write an answer...
1 Answer to this question
Answer-china
邮件内容大意:
我们非常欣赏您论文中表现出的对科研所作的努力。但很遗憾地通知您,在关于原创性审查过程中出现了一些问题。虽然有在可接受范围内的重合度,但是直接引用部分,应当降至最低(这不仅仅是版权问题)。此外,有一些段落直接来自参考文献中的文章。这些段落应当重写,并且应该更加明确地标注,给予更多讨。上述问题,在进入同行评审前就应当已经落实解决。我十分希望你可以顺利解决上述问题,然后提交稿件。当然,再次提交稿件并不意味着最终论文被接受。最终接受与否取决于同行评审员的再次审核。
这份回复信表明您的论文被拒了,因为期刊的自动查重发现您的论文与其他论文有很高的相似性。有可能是你自己以前发表的论文,也有可能是你参考书目中的论文。不过,如果这些问题得以解决,期刊愿意重新考虑你的论文。只要你重新表述内容相似的部分,就可以重新开始新一轮的论文提交。
暂时可以不回复期刊。您应该先解决上述问题,再重新开始新一轮提交。重新提交时,您可以提到稿件ID,并解释您在之前按照指示做了相应的修改。
现在我们来看如何修改稿件。首先,你应该进行查重,确定哪些部分有类似。网上有许多查重工具,选一个能出具详细报告的。根据报告提示,完全改写相应内容,并在正文和参考列表中注明来源。完成之后,再进行一轮查重。尽量将相似内容的百分比控制在10 -15%以内。如果不止这些,再修改一遍。然后,您可以再次将稿件作为新一轮投稿提交给期刊。
相关阅读